| Children |
| – | 1. Estella M. Shafer, b. 15 Sep 1880, Franklin Township, Brown County, Ohio d. 30 Jun 1967, Brown County, Ohio (Age 86 years) |
| | 2. Ethel Blanche Shafer, b. 5 Jan 1883, Franklin Township, Brown County, Ohio d. 6 Jan 1943, Cincinnati, Hamilton County, Ohio (Age 60 years) |
| | 3. Charles Lewis Shafer, b. 25 May 1885, Franklin Township, Brown County, Ohio d. 22 Jun 1974, Mount Orab, Brown County, Ohio (Age 89 years) |
| | 4. John A. Shafer, b. 25 May 1890, Franklin Township, Brown County, Ohio d. 9 Aug 1923, Gallipolis, Gallia County, Ohio (Age 33 years) |
| | 5. Anna L. Shafer, b. 27 Nov 1892, Franklin Township, Brown County, Ohio d. 18 Jul 1986, Cincinnati, Hamilton County, Ohio (Age 93 years) |
| | 6. Earl Franklin Shafer, b. 22 Aug 1896, Franklin Township, Brown County, Ohio d. 9 Jan 1963, Brown County, Ohio (Age 66 years) |
|